“Ms Zhang, Ms Zhang, don’t teach this song, if you continue, I will rip it off…”
I taught Twinkle Twinkle Little Star to one of my Grade 5/6s students in RGPS after they finished their required work in class. Just when we were singing this song together, a boy with high-pitch voice shouted at me “Ms Zhang, Ms Zhang…”
I knew he likes to get my attention by shouting in the class. So I ignored him while I was teaching others.
At the end of the class, he came to me and demanded that I shouldn’t teach this song. I asked him why, he said there was Allah in this song. I was confused and not sure what he was talking about. Few questions later, I understood what he said. Basically he said if we sing the first two lyrics of this song backward we could hear “I wish there were no Allah”.
I asked him where does this idea comes from, he told me that he learned it from internet. One of his classmates asked he “can you believe internet?”. He didn’t answer back. But he was so convinced by this idea that he started to get angry when he felt I was not convinced by him.
“I will rip this paper off if you continue teaching this song. It about my Allah…”
In the end, I told him to ask his father or Imam from Muslim mosque to write something about the relationship between this song and Muslim Allah to me next week. If I was really convienced by him, I will stop teaching this song. He left with “I will rip it off”.
When I was back home, I checked on the internet about the connection between Twinkle Twinkle Little Star and Muslim Allan.There was only one comment on Google website. There was a video on Youtube about it but it is obviously a farfetched comparison between two verses which I couldn’t really find any clue about how this children rhythm offend Muslim Allan.
For example:
“Twinkle twinkle little star, how I wonder what you are”
According to the guy who posts this on the internet, if we sing this lyrics backward it will sound like:
“I wish there were no Allan”
I can’t really see or hear Allan or anything affending Muslim religion in this song even I sing the lyrics backward few times.
Obviously my student believes it is right even though it is really a fallacy.
But I need to take it seriously and talk to this boy next week.
Language class, religion bias, teacher-student relationships… What a day I had on Thursday last week!